Missouri Chief Justice delivers 2014 State of the Judiciary address
Wednesday, January 22, 2014
Posted by: Chuck Ramsay
22 January 2014
Missouri chief justice delivers 2014 State of the Judiciary address
Mary R. Russell, chief
justice of the Supreme Court of Missouri, delivered the
following State of the Judiciary address Wednesday morning, January 22, 2014, during a joint session of the General Assembly in Jefferson City, Mo.
Governor Kinder, Speaker Jones, President Pro Tem Dempsey, members of the
General Assembly, the executive branch, my judicial colleagues and everyone
gathered in this beautiful chamber: I am honored to have this opportunity to speak
to you today.
especially pleased to be here,
because the capitol building holds personal significance for me. It was here
where I learned, first-hand, how the three branches of government work.
I made my
first visit as a high-school senior with Mr. Frank Brown’s government class
from Hannibal High School. Later, as a junior at Truman State University, I interned in the House, observing
how laws were made. By the way, Rep. Chris Kelly was in the House back then too!
I also worked part-time in the Senate president pro tem’s office while working
my way through law school at Mizzou.
I have had
the good fortune to serve in the executive branch of government as well. I was
appointed by Governors Ashcroft and Carnahan to several boards and commissions
that helped carry out the laws adopted by the legislature.
And now I
am in my 18th year serving in the judiciary, where we resolve disputes by
interpreting what laws and constitutional provisions mean, when applied to a
variety of situations – some foreseen, some not.
collective experiences in all three branches of our government continue to
convince me that all of us are truly "constitutional partners” – all equally
sworn to uphold the constitutions of our state and nation – all equally
entrusted by our fellow Missourians to make this state better for them, and
their children, and their children to come.
Perhaps you are like me, having to pinch yourself that you
have the privilege to work in the state capital. For me, it is the honor of
working in the red brick building across the street. For you, it may be seeing
the majestic dome of the capitol rising in the distance as you drive into town and
knowing you have an office there. Our time to do good here is limited, and it
will pass all too quickly. We must make the most of this unique opportunity. For
we are all but temporary guardians of our system of government, and we must
work together to ensure its legacy continues.
is another reason I am honored to be here today.
This speech marks the 40th anniversary of the first state of the judiciary
address in Missouri history, delivered by then-Chief
Justice Robert T. Donnelly. In that speech to the General Assembly in 1974, he
talked about the "exciting opportunities available” for "modernization of our
operations.” He predicted that the impact of technology on government would "be
visionary Chief Justice Donnelly was. His statements about "the impact of … technology”
on the courts were made more than 40 years ago, long before desktop computers,
e-mail and videoconferencing … and maybe before some of you were even born.
in the courts continue to meet the challenge of being innovative in the
services we provide, to maintaining prudent stewardship of public funds and to
working in cooperation with all our "constitutional partners.”
of the 407 state judges and commissioners and the more than 4,000 court clerks
and staff working diligently in each one of your local courthouses back home, I
am proud to say that the state of Missouri’s judiciary is strong. We have been
working smarter by implementing innovative ideas. We are resolving as many
cases as are filed each year in state court. And our judges and staff are working
hard every day to make Missouri’s courts better for everyone. They
deserve our thanks.
Missouri courts continue to be innovative in
Justice Donnelly predicted, incorporating new technologies has been an ongoing
process for the courts. We spent more than a decade deploying our case
management system statewide. It was complete by 2008, and it empowers you and the
public to use Case.net to search for information about cases filed anywhere in
the state. About two years ago, we began changing from paper filings to
electronic filings. Today, the Missouri eFiling System is being used in
every appellate court and 28 trial courts, with another 30 courts ready to come
online later this year. We are rolling this system out as fast as our resources
I am very proud of these achievements in increasing public
access to the courts. They are examples of the kind of innovation in service that
the public has come to expect from both the private sector and government. Like
Case.net, our eFiling System is unique to Missouri. Thanks to an enhancement to
Case.net that we implemented last fall, now you or any of your constituents can
come into any courthouse and use a designated computer terminal to read the
contents of any public document in the Missouri eFiling System. These range from
pleadings and briefs to orders and judgments – no matter where in the state they
Building digital infrastructure into our court services
helps all of government. For instance, our court technology allows the judiciary
and various state agencies and county officials to share more information. This
cooperation and coordination ensures that offenders can be apprehended more
quickly, that people who are granted orders of protection can be kept safer,
and that more child support payments and court fines can be collected. The
bottom line is that sharing this vital court information helps to make all of
government more efficient and more effective.
But we are not stopping there in expanding our services. After
all, technology changes every day. And the public expects almost instant access
to everything. So we are exploring ways to use technology to be more innovative
in the services we provide to all Missourians. For example, we are determining
how electronic tools can help jurors stay informed about when their services
will be needed. We also are devising a way people can pay their fines online. A
new and improved website about Your Missouri Courts is on the horizon as well.
It is also incumbent on the judiciary to help people
understand the function that judges and the courts are assigned. Courts exist
to protect people’s rights and to give them a safe, civil environment in which
to resolve their most pressing disputes. As judges, we are required to decide
cases based solely on the facts and law, not on our personal beliefs or popular
opinion. Like you, we take our oaths very seriously. We cannot promise any
particular outcome in any case, but we do promise to support and defend our constitutions
and to treat everyone with fairness, dignity and respect.
In our system of democracy, it is our duty to protect the rights
and property of all Missourians and to be guardians of the constitution through
which the people govern us all. But no matter how much compassion we might have
for the people involved in legal disputes, judges simply are not in the
"happiness business.” For every decision we make, someone is unhappy, and
sometimes everyone – including the judge – is unhappy.
In the past, judges have done their jobs well by staying in
the courthouse. But more and more, we have found that people can better
understand how the judiciary works by engaging with them in their communities.
One of my favorite parts of being a judge is the chance to
accept as many invitations as my schedule will permit to speak with Missourians
from all walks of life about how their courts work, taking the mystery out of
the process. I have been in towns from Rockport to Kahoka to Caruthersville to
Pineville, from Lebanon to Paris … and Halfway in between … and the
same holds true for my "namesakes,” Maryville and Russellville. But no matter where I go, I find that all Missourians
share certain common expectations – to be treated equally and fairly, and to
have justice administered the same no matter where they live.
This past fall, I was happy to accept Senator Doug Libla’s
invitation to travel to his district to visit some of the wonderful programs helping
his constituents in the Bootheel. In fact, along with some of the program
leaders, five of the young high school students I met in Caruthersville are
here today – Amaud Bates, Tavauna Cobb, Nicole Davis, Shannon Gipson and Angela
Wilhoit. Would you please join me in welcoming them to their state capitol? I
hope that your first trip to the capitol will inspire you – as it did me when I
was your age – to find a place in government service.
I am sure
none of us, when we were in high school, imagined we would wind up here. But none
of us should forget what led us to serve in the first place. That is why I
never want to lose perspective of what it is like for the people who come to
our courthouses, maybe for the first time, and who perhaps are overwhelmed by an
unfamiliar legal process. Every case that comes before our courts is the most
important one in the world to the people involved … people who are worried about
the potential impact on their lives, their families and their pocketbooks.
This is why
we are implementing a program of customer surveys focusing on the people who
use our courts – litigants, witnesses, jurors, lawyers, social workers and
others – as one way to determine how we can do our jobs better and make the
process more transparent.
Instead of a "suggestion box,” I wanted to go talk to people
directly. So this past summer, I became an "undercover judge” by visiting two
courthouses – in Osage and St. Louis counties. I talked with everyone
there using the courts. Dressed in casual clothes and tennis shoes, I don’t
think anyone knew who I was. I sat shoulder to shoulder with people in the courthouse
hallways. I could feel their anxiety, their worry and their apprehension as
they waited their turn to appear before the judge. For most, it was their first
time in any courtroom, and they did not know what to expect. Many did not have
lawyers to help them navigate the unfamiliar turf.
It is important for us to remember that the courts can be a
confusing, daunting place for many who come there. But by listening to those we
serve, we can make the court process a little more understandable and a little
less scary for the average person.
As I told those courthouse visitors last summer – and as I
will tell those in the counties I plan to visit later in the year – this is a
focal point for me. It is not just one of those surveys where nothing happens. We
already are using the information we are learning to see not only what we are
doing well but also how we can improve as we chart our course for the future.
Missouri courts continue to work in
cooperation with their "constitutional partners”
In 1974, Chief Justice Donnelly focused part of his remarks
on criminal justice issues. He discussed a proposed revision of the criminal
code, which he said at that time had "not been totally reviewed in [more than] a
that undertaking, although I had not yet even entered law school. It was about 1979,
and I was a young cub reporter for the Hannibal Courier-Post, assigned to write
about the new criminal code that was taking effect. I hate to date myself, but
another 35 years have passed, and I am glad you are considering another update
so that our criminal justice system may better serve the state.
there were 232 offenses that were charged only one time anywhere in the state and
130 other offenses that were charged only twice. I think we can all agree that
some sensible efforts at streamlining our criminal code are warranted. Our
current criminal code has some discrepancies calling into question the concept
of "if you do the crime, you’ll do the time.” For instance, if a person drives
a vehicle while intoxicated and kills someone, that person may be punished by
up to seven years in state prison. But that is the same punishment for a person
who writes a bad check for less than $500. Is that being smart
It is your
prerogative to determine where the problems truly lie and what solutions are
most appropriate. We appreciate your careful study – in which you have sought
information from prosecutors, public defenders and other lawyers – of updating
our criminal code, and we in the courts remain committed to help answer any
questions you may have from our perspective. We know how difficult this issue
is, and we know it may be hard to reach agreement. But we trust that all of
your hard work will produce an improved criminal code that will be beneficial
for our entire state.
changed since Chief Justice Donnelly’s days on the Court. Today, our state and
municipal courts handle more than 2.5 million cases each year. Much also has
changed in the types of evidence we consider. It is not uncommon today to have
evidence of DNA and Facebook entries, not to mention tweets and texts and selfies. And
so the need for continuing judicial education is critical, and we are proud of
the programs we have in place to keep our judges up to date about new laws and new
Missouri courts continue to be prudent
stewards of public funds
thing that has not changed is our continued commitment to being prudent
stewards of public funds. One example is a new effort underway to better manage
adults awaiting trial for criminal charges, which can be a big relief for
counties that are financially strapped because of jail overcrowding.
pretrial services programs are proving their worth. They keep potentially
dangerous offenders off the street before trial but allow those who pose no
known threat to be monitored outside of jail while awaiting their court
appearance. These programs result in significant savings for counties and their
taxpayers by reducing jail overcrowding.
Greene County has seen dramatic savings. In the last two years alone, its
program resulted in a net savings of almost $4 million – even with the cost of
the staff running the program included.
results like these, it should not surprise you that similar programs exist in Cole,
Boone and Jackson counties as well and that several other counties are
considering adding the program. I encourage you to partner with your local
officials to determine whether a program like this might help your county save
money. In Greene County, local judges worked with their county
commission to establish the pretrial services program there. Those judges – Don
Burrell, Mark Powell and Miles Sweeney – are here today along with one of their
county commissioners, Roseann Bentley. Would you all please stand and be
of how the courts are working with our partners throughout government to be
prudent stewards of the public’s resources is the increased use of videoconferencing.
This technology, which replaces in-person hearings, results in reduced
transportation costs for counties and the department of corrections alike. It
also decreases the risk to law enforcement officers while increasing public
safety. In addition, videoconferencing is useful in mental health cases,
preserving the dignity of the person involved. As we develop more uses for this
technology, these savings will continue to grow.
We have partnered with you to create several programs that
improve our financial stewardship and aid the entire state. Income tax offsets,
debt collection efforts and allowing litigants to pay court debts over time have
resulted in almost $26 million in revenue to the state that otherwise would
have gone uncollected. And this money goes not to the courts, but to the state and
local entities you designate.
Through efforts like these, we in the courts are doing what
we can – as one co-equal branch of government – to be efficient with the
public’s funding. We look forward to continuing to work with you and with all our
government partners in the future to provide even more responsible stewardship.
the work you do and the many tough decisions you face as you write the laws for
our state. We also appreciate the sacrifices that you and your loved ones make
so that you can serve in these majestic chambers. Family support is essential
for any of us to do our jobs. Like you, I have enjoyed the support of a wonderful
family along the way, and they have made even the toughest days of my career
more meaningful. I’d like to acknowledge one of them now. Would you please
welcome my husband, Jim, a former member of this House?
In honor of
this 40th anniversary of the first state of the judiciary, I end with some of
Chief Justice Donnelly’s closing remarks: "We seek, as you do, to be a strong,
contributing partner to our Missouri state government … to serve our
citizens in a responsive and responsible manner. … [W]e can do it together.”
constitutional partners, we look forward to working with you to make Missouri’s courts better for everyone. Thank